Scrumbles Turkey Wet vs Years Vet Turkey Thigh Fresh

Pros

• ✓65% named turkey with no by-products or meat meal — transparent, high-quality protein sourcing
• ✓Slippery elm inclusion provides evidence-based gut support, particularly for IBD and sensitive stomachs
• ✓Exceptional palatability — multiple reviewers note even very fussy or medically sensitive dogs eat it enthusiastically
• ✓Grain-free and hypoallergenic formulation reduces common dietary triggers

Cons

• ✗Foil lid frequently reported as difficult to open and prone to splattering
• ✗Elevated dry-matter fat (~46%) may be unsuitable for dogs with pancreatitis or obesity
• ✗150g pouches require multiple units per day for medium to large breeds, increasing cost
• ✗Limited protein variety in the range (no beef option noted by reviewers)

Best For

Pros

• ✓60% turkey from named cuts (leg, heart, liver) with no by-products or meat meal
• ✓Added taurine (0.25%) plus organ meat, which supports heart and overall function
• ✓Fully transparent label — every ingredient carries a declared percentage
• ✓Strong palatability: several reviewers report fussy dogs eating it readily

Cons

• ✗Expensive for the quantity — several owners flagged small portions and poor value
• ✗No portion or feeding guidance included on the Amazon listing
• ✗One reviewer reported their dog vomiting repeatedly after eating it
• ✗One reviewer found the food had gone mouldy within a few days of opening

Best For