Scrumbles Turkey Wet vs Forthglade Senior Turkey & Veg

Pros

• ✓65% named turkey with no by-products or meat meal — transparent, high-quality protein sourcing
• ✓Slippery elm inclusion provides evidence-based gut support, particularly for IBD and sensitive stomachs
• ✓Exceptional palatability — multiple reviewers note even very fussy or medically sensitive dogs eat it enthusiastically
• ✓Grain-free and hypoallergenic formulation reduces common dietary triggers

Cons

• ✗Foil lid frequently reported as difficult to open and prone to splattering
• ✗Elevated dry-matter fat (~46%) may be unsuitable for dogs with pancreatitis or obesity
• ✗150g pouches require multiple units per day for medium to large breeds, increasing cost
• ✗Limited protein variety in the range (no beef option noted by reviewers)

Best For

Pros

• ✓60% named turkey — high-quality single protein source with no vague by-products or meat derivatives
• ✓Strong palatability reports, including fussy eaters and dogs that had previously refused food
• ✓Multiple reviews confirm improved digestion and stool consistency, especially in sensitive-stomach dogs
• ✓Lower fat content and lighter calories are appropriate for senior dogs prone to weight gain

Cons

• ✗Texture described as smooth and paste-like by some owners, which not all dogs accept
• ✗Historical carrageenan use in seaweed binder caused digestive upset in a subset of dogs — formulation has been updated but older reviews may still reflect this
• ✗Fibre content is very low (0.2% as-fed) — senior dogs with constipation or colonic health issues may benefit from higher fibre
• ✗Some dogs went off the food after months of use, suggesting palatability can fade over time without rotation

Best For