Skip to content

New Leaf Zinc vs Thorne Zinc Picolinate

Ad: we earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never affects our scores or rankings. How we make money

Side-by-side comparison of scores, ingredients, prices and real customer feedback for New Leaf Zinc and Thorne Zinc Picolinate.

Last verified: 10 Nov 2026 · Based on 59 reviews

Our Verdict: New Leaf Zinc or Thorne Zinc Picolinate?

Thorne wins with an 85 vs 71 overall score, backed by superior ingredient quality (91 vs 76) and a safer 22mg dose that stays within UK recommended limits. New Leaf's 50mg dose exceeds upper tolerable intake and has triggered headaches in reviewers, making unsupervised daily use a concern. Budget-conscious buyers who need short-term immune support and are aware of the dosage risk may find New Leaf's £7.95 price hard to ignore versus £21.38 for Thorne.

— AIScored analysis

71.0
Score Summary

New Leaf Zinc scores 71.0/100 vs Thorne Zinc Picolinate at 71.0/100. New Leaf Zinc wins on value for money, certifications. Thorne Zinc Picolinate is stronger on effectiveness and ingredient quality.

How Do the Scores Compare?

Zinc 50mg High Strength Tab...
Zinc Picolinate 22mg
Zinc 50mg High Strength Tablets with Copper, Pure Zinc Supplements Contributes Towards The Immune System, Bone Health and Fertility, Vegan, Non-GMO, Made in UK by New Leaf 120 Tablets
Zinc 50mg High Strength Tab...
New Leaf Products
Zinc Picolinate 22mg
Zinc Picolinate 22mg
Thorne
Overall Score 71.0 71.0
Effectiveness 71.0/100 77.0/100
Best
Ingredient Quality 76.0/100 80.0/100
Best
Value for Money 81.0/100
Best
68.0/100
Side Effects 62.0/100 84.0/100
Best
Certifications 67.0/100
Best
35.0/100
Best Price
£8.95
£7.15 Amazon UK →
-20% deal
£13.17 Amazon UK →
Out of stock
Form Tablet N/A
Dose N/A N/A
Third-Party Tested Maker’s claim ✗ No
Reviews Analysed 12 47

Zinc 50mg High Strength Tablets ...

Pros

  • ✓Small, easy-to-swallow tablets praised by multiple reviewers as a standout feature
  • ✓Zinc citrate form has good bioavailability — superior to zinc oxide used in cheaper alternatives
  • ✓Copper included to counteract zinc-induced copper depletion — a responsible formulation choice
  • ✓Strong value for money; 120 tablets providing a 2-month supply at competitive pricing

Cons

  • ✗50mg per serving (500% NRV) significantly exceeds EU and UK upper tolerable intake levels (~25mg/day) for unsupervised daily use
  • ✗At least one reviewer reported headaches upon use — consistent with known high-dose zinc side effects
  • ✗Minor packaging complaint: safety cap reportedly difficult to open
  • ✗Product listing claims 'Vegan' in the title and description, but product data flags this as unconfirmed — prospective vegan buyers should verify directly

Best For

Adults with confirmed or suspected zinc deficiency Those seeking immune support during winter or high-stress periods Individuals with skin concerns, acne, or slow wound healing Men interested in supporting normal testosterone levels and fertility
View full review →

Zinc Picolinate 22mg

Pros

  • ✓Many reviewers say they had fewer colds or got over them faster, with a few taking it alongside vitamin C
  • ✓Several reviewers report clearer skin, fewer rashes or less acne, plus stronger nails and less hair loss
  • ✓Picolinate is a chelated zinc form that is generally well absorbed
  • ✓Several reviewers say it's gentle on the stomach. One said a 30mg zinc from another brand made them sick but this one didn't

Cons

  • ✗The product listing is inconsistent. The title says Thorne, the description says Solgar tablets, and reviewers describe 15mg Thorne capsules rather than 22mg
  • ✗The specs give no third-party testing or certification information
  • ✗One reviewer found the smell 'specific, cheesy' and another said the taste isn't great
  • ✗One reviewer said delivery took about two weeks

Best For

People who get nauseous from other zinc supplements and want a gentler chelated form Adults using zinc for skin, nail or hair-loss concerns People who want a zinc to keep in the cupboard for cold season
View full review →

Score Breakdown: New Leaf Zinc vs Thorne Zinc Picolinate

New Leaf Zinc Winner 71.0/100

New Leaf Products' zinc supplement delivers 50mg elemental zinc per two-tablet serving in the citrate form, which offers notably better bioavailability than the cheaper zinc oxide found in many budget supplements.

Effectiveness
Zinc 50mg High S..
71.0/100
Zinc Picolinate 22mg
77.0/100
Ingredient Quality
Zinc 50mg High S..
76.0/100
Zinc Picolinate 22mg
80.0/100
Value for Money
Zinc 50mg High S..
81.0/100
Zinc Picolinate 22mg
68.0/100
Side Effects
Zinc 50mg High S..
62.0/100
Zinc Picolinate 22mg
84.0/100
Certifications
Zinc 50mg High S..
67.0/100
Zinc Picolinate 22mg
35.0/100

What are the key differences?

New Leaf Zinc is best for: Adults with confirmed or suspected zinc deficiency, Those seeking immune support during winter or high-stress periods
Thorne Zinc Picolinate is best for: People who get nauseous from other zinc supplements and want a gentler chelated form, Adults using zinc for skin, nail or hair-loss concerns

Frequently Asked Questions

Which is better, New Leaf Zinc or Thorne Zinc Picolinate? ▼
Thorne wins with an 85 vs 71 overall score, backed by superior ingredient quality (91 vs 76) and a safer 22mg dose that stays within UK recommended limits. New Leaf's 50mg dose exceeds upper tolerable intake and has triggered headaches in reviewers, making unsupervised daily use a concern. Budget-conscious buyers who need short-term immune support and are aware of the dosage risk may find New Leaf's £7.95 price hard to ignore versus £21.38 for Thorne. New Leaf Zinc scores 71.0/100 overall while Thorne Zinc Picolinate scores 71.0/100. Both score equally overall — the difference comes down to individual dimensions. New Leaf Zinc is best suited for Adults with confirmed or suspected zinc deficiency and Those seeking immune support during winter or high-stress periods. Thorne Zinc Picolinate is better for People who get nauseous from other zinc supplements and want a gentler chelated form and Adults using zinc for skin, nail or hair-loss concerns.
Is New Leaf Zinc worth the price compared to Thorne Zinc Picolinate? ▼
New Leaf Zinc costs £7.15 while Thorne Zinc Picolinate is £13.17. For value, New Leaf Zinc scores 81.0/100 vs Thorne Zinc Picolinate's 68.0/100. New Leaf Zinc delivers better value relative to its quality.
Which has fewer side effects? ▼
New Leaf Zinc scores 62.0/100 for side effects (higher means fewer reported issues) while Thorne Zinc Picolinate scores 84.0/100. Reviewers report fewer side effects with Thorne Zinc Picolinate. For certification and testing, New Leaf Zinc scores 67.0/100 vs Thorne Zinc Picolinate's 35.0/100. Always consult a healthcare professional before starting any supplement.

Related Product Comparisons

Disclaimer: AIScored provides data-driven comparisons based on publicly available reviews. This is not medical advice. Affiliate links may earn us a commission at no extra cost to you.

Feedback & Suggestions

Spotted an issue? Wrong price, incorrect data, or something else off? Let us know and we'll fix it.

Missing a product you'd like us to review? Tell us the product name and we'll consider adding it.