Skip to content

Solgar Zinc Picolinate vs New Leaf Zinc

Ad: we earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never affects our scores or rankings. How we make money

Side-by-side comparison of scores, ingredients, prices and real customer feedback for Solgar Zinc Picolinate and New Leaf Zinc.

Last verified: 10 Nov 2026 · Based on 59 reviews

Our Verdict: Solgar Zinc Picolinate or New Leaf Zinc?

Solgar wins on effectiveness and ingredient quality (80 and 82 vs 71 and 76), with zinc picolinate offering superior absorption at just £2 more. New Leaf suits budget-conscious buyers, but its 50mg dose far exceeds safe daily limits — use only under medical supervision.

— AIScored analysis

79.0
Score Summary

Solgar Zinc Picolinate scores 79.0/100 vs New Leaf Zinc at 71.0/100. Solgar Zinc Picolinate wins on effectiveness, ingredient quality, side effects. New Leaf Zinc is stronger on value for money.

Solgar Zinc Picolinate vs New Leaf Zinc: What Does the Data Say?

Solgar Zinc Picolinate uses zinc picolinate at 22mg per tablet — 200% of the daily value, a sensible and well-studied dose. New Leaf goes considerably higher at 50mg, which is 500% of the NRV and meaningfully above the UK upper tolerable intake of around 25mg per day for unsupervised use. Solgar scores 82 for ingredient quality versus New Leaf's 76, partly reflecting that picolinate form and its cleaner excipient profile. New Leaf does include copper alongside zinc, which is genuinely responsible — high-dose zinc depletes copper over time — but the dose itself remains a concern for everyday use without medical guidance.

If you have a confirmed deficiency or want reliable daily supplementation without worrying about upper limits, Solgar at £9.99 is the safer, better-tested option. It's vegan, Kosher, Halal, and third-party tested — reassuring credentials. New Leaf at £7.95 scores 81 for value versus Solgar's 62, and for someone who only needs occasional short-term supplementation under supervision, the lower price and copper inclusion have merit.

Practically speaking, Solgar's tablets are slightly larger due to excipients, while New Leaf reviewers specifically praise how easy their tablets are to swallow. Neither contains common allergens, and both are non-GMO. The headaches reported by some New Leaf users are a known side effect of high-dose zinc — worth bearing in mind before committing to a 120-tablet bottle.

How Do the Scores Compare?

Solgar Zinc Picolinate 22mg
Zinc 50mg High Strength Tab...
Solgar Zinc Picolinate 22mg
Solgar Zinc Picolinate 22mg
Solgar
Zinc 50mg High Strength Tablets with Copper, Pure Zinc Supplements Contributes Towards The Immune System, Bone Health and Fertility, Vegan, Non-GMO, Made in UK by New Leaf 120 Tablets
Zinc 50mg High Strength Tab...
New Leaf Products
Overall Score 79.0 71.0
Effectiveness 79.0/100
Best
71.0/100
Ingredient Quality 82.0/100
Best
76.0/100
Value for Money 78.0/100 81.0/100
Best
Side Effects 84.0/100
Best
62.0/100
Certifications 70.0/100
Best
67.0/100
Best Price
£13.03
£6.26 Amazon UK →
-52% deal
£8.95
£7.15 Amazon UK →
-20% deal
Price per Serving £0.06 100 servings
Best value
£0.12 60 servings
Form Tablets Tablet
Dose 22mg (200% DV) N/A
Third-Party Tested ✓ Yes Maker’s claim
Reviews Analysed 47 12

Solgar Zinc Picolinate 22mg

Pros

  • ✓Many reviewers say they catch fewer colds or recover faster, especially in winter
  • ✓Many report clearer, calmer skin, and some mention fewer rashes and less acne
  • ✓Several reviewers say it caused no stomach pain or nausea, including two who had problems with other zinc products
  • ✓Several say their hair loss slowed or stopped, and two were recommended it by a trichologist or cosmetologist

Cons

  • ✗Tablets need more excipients than capsule zinc (dicalcium phosphate, microcrystalline cellulose, silica, magnesium stearate), so the label isn't as clean
  • ✗Two reviewers found the tablets a bit large or awkward to swallow, though most called them small
  • ✗One reviewer got nausea when taking it on an empty stomach
  • ✗Some 5-star reviews are generic or describe things that don't fit this product (scent, capsules, digestion), which inflates the overall picture

Best For

People who want daily zinc for immune support in the cold season People with acne-prone or easily inflamed skin who want to try zinc People with hair loss who are looking at zinc status, ideally with guidance from a professional People whose stomachs react badly to other zinc products
View full review →

Zinc 50mg High Strength Tablets ...

Pros

  • ✓Small, easy-to-swallow tablets praised by multiple reviewers as a standout feature
  • ✓Zinc citrate form has good bioavailability — superior to zinc oxide used in cheaper alternatives
  • ✓Copper included to counteract zinc-induced copper depletion — a responsible formulation choice
  • ✓Strong value for money; 120 tablets providing a 2-month supply at competitive pricing

Cons

  • ✗50mg per serving (500% NRV) significantly exceeds EU and UK upper tolerable intake levels (~25mg/day) for unsupervised daily use
  • ✗At least one reviewer reported headaches upon use — consistent with known high-dose zinc side effects
  • ✗Minor packaging complaint: safety cap reportedly difficult to open
  • ✗Product listing claims 'Vegan' in the title and description, but product data flags this as unconfirmed — prospective vegan buyers should verify directly

Best For

Adults with confirmed or suspected zinc deficiency Those seeking immune support during winter or high-stress periods Individuals with skin concerns, acne, or slow wound healing Men interested in supporting normal testosterone levels and fertility
View full review →

Score Breakdown: Solgar Zinc Picolinate vs New Leaf Zinc

Solgar Zinc Picolinate Winner 79.0/100

Solgar Zinc Picolinate gives you 22mg of zinc (200% DV) per tablet in picolinate form, a chelated form generally considered well absorbed, and one bottle covers 100 days at one tablet a day.

Effectiveness
Solgar Zinc Pico..
79.0/100
Zinc 50mg High S..
71.0/100
Ingredient Quality
Solgar Zinc Pico..
82.0/100
Zinc 50mg High S..
76.0/100
Value for Money
Solgar Zinc Pico..
78.0/100
Zinc 50mg High S..
81.0/100
Side Effects
Solgar Zinc Pico..
84.0/100
Zinc 50mg High S..
62.0/100
Certifications
Solgar Zinc Pico..
70.0/100
Zinc 50mg High S..
67.0/100

What are the key differences?

Solgar Zinc Picolinate is best for: People who want daily zinc for immune support in the cold season, People with acne-prone or easily inflamed skin who want to try zinc
New Leaf Zinc is best for: Adults with confirmed or suspected zinc deficiency, Those seeking immune support during winter or high-stress periods

Frequently Asked Questions

Which is better, Solgar Zinc Picolinate or New Leaf Zinc? ▼
Solgar wins on effectiveness and ingredient quality (80 and 82 vs 71 and 76), with zinc picolinate offering superior absorption at just £2 more. New Leaf suits budget-conscious buyers, but its 50mg dose far exceeds safe daily limits — use only under medical supervision. Solgar Zinc Picolinate scores 79.0/100 overall while New Leaf Zinc scores 71.0/100. Solgar Zinc Picolinate comes out ahead, scoring higher on effectiveness (79.0 vs 71.0). Solgar Zinc Picolinate is best suited for People who want daily zinc for immune support in the cold season and People with acne-prone or easily inflamed skin who want to try zinc. New Leaf Zinc is better for Adults with confirmed or suspected zinc deficiency and Those seeking immune support during winter or high-stress periods.
Is Solgar Zinc Picolinate worth the price compared to New Leaf Zinc? ▼
Solgar Zinc Picolinate costs £6.26 while New Leaf Zinc is £7.15. For value, Solgar Zinc Picolinate scores 78.0/100 vs New Leaf Zinc's 81.0/100. New Leaf Zinc delivers better value relative to its quality. Note that Solgar Zinc Picolinate comes as tablets while New Leaf Zinc is tablet, which may affect your preference.
Which has fewer side effects? ▼
Solgar Zinc Picolinate scores 84.0/100 for side effects (higher means fewer reported issues) while New Leaf Zinc scores 62.0/100. Reviewers report fewer side effects with Solgar Zinc Picolinate. For certification and testing, Solgar Zinc Picolinate scores 70.0/100 vs New Leaf Zinc's 67.0/100. Always consult a healthcare professional before starting any supplement.

Related Product Comparisons

Disclaimer: AIScored provides data-driven comparisons based on publicly available reviews. This is not medical advice. Affiliate links may earn us a commission at no extra cost to you.

Feedback & Suggestions

Spotted an issue? Wrong price, incorrect data, or something else off? Let us know and we'll fix it.

Missing a product you'd like us to review? Tell us the product name and we'll consider adding it.