Skip to content

Extra Select Puppy Bones

Full listing title: Extra Select Puppy Bones Dog Treat Biscuits in a 3ltr Bucket (approx 1070 biscuits)

by Extra Select

Ad: we earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never affects our scores or rankings. How we make money

· 10 reviews analysed · 1 source · Price data: 18 Nov 2026 · Medium confidence · Scored by AI · Run by Bartek
Extra Select Puppy Bones Dog Treat Biscuits in a 3ltr Bucket (approx 1070 biscuits)
52
Overall Score
Average

Compare Prices

Amazon UK
£13.58 View →

Lowest price in the last 90 days: £13.01 at Amazon UK (12 Nov). Price history

Verdict: Average View Dog Treats Rankings →

Extra Select Puppy Bones are small vanilla-flavoured biscuit treats with a modest 8% protein and 7.9% fat profile, strongly indicative of a predominantly cereal/grain-based formulation rather than a meat-led recipe. Best for Basic reward-based training for puppies and small dogs (1–5 kg) and Budget-conscious owners seeking a high-volume treat for everyday rewards.

Is Extra Select Puppy Bones worth buying?

“Extra Select Puppy Bones offer exceptional value with around 1,070 tiny biscuits per bucket, perfect for training sessions and small breeds that genuinely love them. At 52/100, they're a decent occasional treat but the grain-heavy formulation means they're best used as training rewards rather than a dietary staple.”

— AIScored analysis, Mar 2026

What Do Reviewers Say About Extra Select Puppy Bones?

Sample excerpts from currently available source material used in this product analysis.

"Handy sized tub of small biscuits which my elderly Whippet loves as he 's never cared for normal dog biscuits, even though his teeth are ok. Recommend & would buy again, thanks."

Amazon • Roo. • 07 Feb 2026

"Not to my liking but my dog LOVED them! Has even tried to sneak them out of my pockets and pouches!! Easy on the stomach. Don't break to easily that there are crumbs everywhere. He would definitely recommend them🐶🤣"

Amazon • Julie Caslaw • 07 Dec 2025

"These biscuits are ideal for puppies. My puppy loves them. Very good price. Will buy them again"

Amazon • Louise • 21 Aug 2025

"My three dogs love these! They're ideal as "get back in the house" snacks, and we love using them for training. They smell like pure sugar though and the ingredients aren't the best for health, but they're well priced and a great occasional..."

Amazon • Victoria • 05 Jul 2025

"Great product , dog's love them as a reward on walks. I bought this tub thinking would be economical than local petshop, however it is actually cheaper to buy from local petshop. Still good value and great product"

Amazon • Nicola Hobson • 26 Jan 2025

How does Extra Select Puppy Bones score?

Detailed score breakdown and key findings from our analysis of 10 reviews across 1 source.

Ingredient Quality Named meats, no by-products, quality protein sources
32.0/100
Below Average
Nutritional Value Protein/fat/fibre balance, meets FEDIAF standards
30.0/100
Below Average
Value for Money Price relative to quality, based on reviewers
82.0/100
Very Good
Transparency Clear labeling, specific ingredients, no vague terms
35.0/100
Below Average
Palatability How much dogs enjoy eating it based on owner reviews
88.0/100
Very Good
Overall Score Overall assessment across all factors
52.0/100
Average

Pros

  • +Extremely high palatability — dogs consistently enthusiastic and motivated by the treat
  • +Ideal small size (~2 cm) for training sessions and mini/toy breeds
  • +Excellent value for money — approximately 1,070 biscuits per 3L bucket at a competitive price point
  • +Low crumble rate reported — minimal mess during training
  • +Reported to be easy on the stomach by multiple reviewers

Cons

  • -Very low protein (8%) with no named meat source — strongly suggests cereal-primary formulation with little or no meaningful animal protein
  • -Vanilla flavouring (likely artificial) adds no nutritional value and is an unnecessary additive for young dogs
  • -Sugar-like aroma noted by owners — possible added sugars or sweeteners, inappropriate for puppies long-term
  • -Recurring packaging complaints: bucket lid prone to cracking or opening in transit, causing spilled biscuits

Best For

Basic reward-based training for puppies and small dogs (1–5 kg) Budget-conscious owners seeking a high-volume treat for everyday rewards Dogs who are fussy about harder biscuit textures — texture is consistently well received Elderly or small dogs with delicate teeth who enjoy light biscuits

Watch Out

  • !Not suitable as a nutritional supplement — grain-heavy, low protein, use only as occasional treats
  • !Vanilla flavouring and potential added sweeteners: avoid feeding in high quantities, especially to very young or sensitive puppies
  • !Dogs with grain intolerance or carbohydrate sensitivity (e.g. diabetic or overweight dogs) should avoid
  • !Fragile bucket lid — store in a secondary container to prevent opportunistic access by the dog

Product description

From the brand and retailer listings.

  • • Small Dog Treats: These puppy training treats are approximately 2cm, a perfect mini size for smaller mouths.
  • • Nutrious Snacks: 8% protein and 7.9% fat ensure each dog treat contains all the puppy essentials to grow big and strong.
  • • Dog Training Treats: Use these puppy bones to make reward-based training sessions more fun and effective.
  • • Delicious Flavour: The vanilla flavour of these dog biscuits & snacks make them high value dog treats that young dogs love.
  • • Flexible Feeding: These dog treats for small dogs fit easily into their regular doggy diets, great for everyday rewards.

Dog Food Details

Food Type
Treats
Suitable For
Puppy
Dog Size
Mini (1-5 kg)

How we score products →

How Does Extra Select Puppy Bones Compare?

See how this product stacks up against the top-rated dog treats in our database.

Product Score Price
Extra Select Puppy Bones Dog Tre... (this) 52.0 £13.58
Lily's Kitchen Natural Dog Treat... 85.0 £26.23
Lily’s Kitchen Made with Natural... 84.0 £23.35
WOOLF Soft Duck Fillet Dog Treat... 82.0 £2.79

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the best price for Extra Select Puppy Bones in the UK? ▼
The best price we found is £13.58 at Amazon UK. We compare prices from 1 UK retailer and update them regularly.
How does Extra Select Puppy Bones compare to Lily's Kitchen Treats Multipack? ▼
Extra Select Puppy Bones scores 52.0/100 while Lily's Kitchen Treats Multipack scores 85.0/100.
What dogs is Extra Select Puppy Bones suitable for? ▼
Extra Select Puppy Bones is suitable for puppy dogs.

Disclaimer: AIScored provides research-backed summaries based on publicly available reviews and product information. This is not medical advice. Always consult a healthcare professional before starting any supplement regimen. Affiliate links may earn us a commission at no extra cost to you.

£13.58
at Amazon UK
View deal →

Feedback & Suggestions

Spotted an issue? Wrong price, incorrect data, or something else off? Let us know and we'll fix it.

Missing a product you'd like us to review? Tell us the product name and we'll consider adding it.