Solgar Skin Nails Hair Formula vs Shivay Herbals Marine Collagen

Q: Which is better, Solgar Skin Nails Hair Formula or Shivay Herbals Marine Collagen?

Solgar Skin Nails Hair Formula scores 75/100 while Shivay Herbals Marine Collagen scores 70/100 in our analysis. Solgar Skin Nails Hair Formula is the higher-rated product overall.

Q: Is Solgar Skin Nails Hair Formula worth the price compared to Shivay Herbals Marine Collagen?

Solgar Skin Nails Hair Formula scores 70.0/100 for value, while Shivay Herbals Marine Collagen scores 91.0/100. Shivay Herbals Marine Collagen delivers better value overall.

Side-by-side comparison of scores, ingredients, prices and real customer feedback for Solgar Skin Nails Hair Formula and Shivay Herbals Marine Collagen.

Last verified: 01 Mar 2026 · Based on 73 reviews

Back to comparison hub View skin, hair & nails guide

75.0

Score Summary

Solgar Skin Nails Hair Formula scores 75.0/100 vs Shivay Herbals Marine Collagen at 70.0/100. Solgar Skin Nails Hair Formula wins on effectiveness, ingredient quality, certifications. Shivay Herbals Marine Collagen is stronger on value for money and side effects.

Solgar Skin Nails Hair Formula vs Shivay Herbals Marine Collagen: What Does the Data Say?

Skin, Nails and Hair Formula 120 Tablets scores 75.0/100 overall and beats Marine Collagen Complex with Vitamin C, Hyaluronic Acid, Biotin on effectiveness at 76.0/100 versus 65.0/100. It also leads on ingredient quality with 82.0/100 against 70.0/100. The two products differ sharply in makeup. Skin, Nails and Hair Formula 120 Tablets uses bioavailable forms such as zinc citrate and copper bisglycinate plus collagen co-factors including L-lysine, L-proline and vitamin C in tablet form. Marine Collagen Complex with Vitamin C, Hyaluronic Acid, Biotin delivers hydrolysed Type I marine collagen at a 1,000mg daily dose together with Vitamin C, Hyaluronic Acid and Biotin inside capsules.

People who notice clear nail strength gains within two to four weeks or want less hair shedding should pick Skin, Nails and Hair Formula 120 Tablets at £13.90. Those after the cheapest way to take collagen every day and who hate any taste from powders will do better with Marine Collagen Complex with Vitamin C, Hyaluronic Acid, Biotin at £9.99 which gives exceptional value at 91.0/100. Vegans who need a collagen-support formula without animal sources need to choose the Solgar option. Budget shoppers happy with a lower dose can save money with the Shivay Herbals capsules.

Both products come in large pills that some reviewers find hard to swallow. Marine Collagen Complex with Vitamin C, Hyaluronic Acid, Biotin leaves no taste or aftertaste at all which helps daily use. Skin benefits arrive more slowly than nail or hair changes with the Solgar tablets.

How Do the Scores Compare?

Skin, Nails and Hair Formul...

Marine Collagen Complex wit...

	Skin, Nails and Hair Formul... Solgar	Marine Collagen Complex wit... Shivay Herbals
Overall Score	75.0	70.0
Effectiveness	76.0/100 Best	65.0/100
Ingredient Quality	82.0/100 Best	70.0/100
Value for Money	70.0/100	91.0/100 Best
Side Effects	78.0/100	93.0/100 Best
Certifications	45.0/100 Best	38.0/100
Best Price	£12.87 Amazon UK →	£9.99 Amazon UK → Cheapest
Form	tablet	‎Capsule
Dose	None	None
Third-Party Tested	✗ No	✗ No
Reviews Analysed	61	12

Skin, Nails and Hair Formula 120 Tablets

Pros

✓Nail strength and growth is the most consistently reported benefit, often noticed within 2–4 weeks
✓Hair improvements widely reported — less shedding, increased shine, and thicker-feeling roots
✓Well-formulated with bioavailable forms (zinc citrate, copper bisglycinate) and collagen co-factors (L-lysine, L-proline, vitamin C)
✓Vegan-friendly with a clean ingredient profile and no artificial sweeteners, salt, or starch

Cons

✗Tablets are notably large and can be difficult to swallow — a frequent complaint across platforms
✗Skin benefits are the least dramatic and slowest to materialise compared to nails and hair
✗No third-party testing or certification (e.g. Informed Sport, NSF) disclosed
✗Zinc content (15mg at 150% NRV) may cause mild nausea if taken on an empty stomach

Best For

Women experiencing brittle or slow-growing nails Those with postpartum hair thinning or increased shedding Vegans seeking a collagen-support formula without animal-derived collagen Adults over 40 whose collagen and keratin production is naturally declining Users who prioritise brand reputation and ingredient quality over lowest price

Amazon UK £12.87 Holland & Barrett £20.53

View full review →

Marine Collagen Complex with Vit...

Pros

✓Exceptional value — approximately £9.99 for a 60-day supply works out to around £5 per month, significantly cheaper than collagen liquids and powders
✓No taste or aftertaste reported across all reviewers, making daily compliance straightforward for those sensitive to collagen flavour or odour
✓Well-rounded formula: hydrolysed Type I marine collagen combined with Vitamin C (EFSA-approved collagen-formation claim), Hyaluronic Acid, and Biotin
✓Made in the UK under GMP standards, free from GMOs and artificial colours — reassurance of basic quality control

Cons

✗1,000mg daily dose is at the low end of the therapeutic range — clinical research on skin and joint outcomes typically uses 2.5–10g per day; powder alternatives commonly deliver 5–10g per serving
✗Capsules described as notably large by multiple reviewers — may be a challenge for those with swallowing difficulties
✗No independent third-party testing (e.g. Informed Sport, NSF, Labdoor) — quality assurance relies solely on the manufacturer's own GMP declaration
✗Not suitable for vegetarians, vegans, or those with fish allergies — contains fish-derived collagen

Best For

Budget-conscious shoppers seeking an affordable daily collagen habit People who dislike the taste, smell, or texture of collagen powders and liquids Women over 30 noticing early signs of collagen decline — fine lines, brittle nails, hair thinning Collagen beginners wanting a low-cost, low-commitment entry point before investing in higher-dose formats UK consumers who prefer domestically manufactured supplements with clear ingredient labelling

Amazon UK £9.99

View full review →

Score Breakdown: Solgar Skin Nails Hair Formula vs Shivay Herbals Marine Collagen

Solgar Skin Nails Hair Formula Winner 75.0/100

Solgar's Skin, Nails & Hair Advanced MSM Formula is a well-regarded beauty supplement combining MSM (1000mg), vitamin C, zinc citrate, copper bisglycinate, and collagen-supporting amino acids (L-lysine and L-proline).

Effectiveness

Skin, Nails and ..

76.0/100

Marine Collagen ..

65.0/100

Ingredient Quality

Skin, Nails and ..

82.0/100

Marine Collagen ..

70.0/100

Value for Money

Skin, Nails and ..

70.0/100

Marine Collagen ..

91.0/100

Side Effects

Skin, Nails and ..

78.0/100

Marine Collagen ..

93.0/100

Certifications

Skin, Nails and ..

45.0/100

Marine Collagen ..

38.0/100

What are the key differences?

Solgar Skin Nails Hair Formula is best for: Women experiencing brittle or slow-growing nails, Those with postpartum hair thinning or increased shedding

Shivay Herbals Marine Collagen is best for: Budget-conscious shoppers seeking an affordable daily collagen habit, People who dislike the taste, smell, or texture of collagen powders and liquids

Frequently Asked Questions

Which is better, Solgar Skin Nails Hair Formula or Shivay Herbals Marine Collagen? ▼

Solgar Skin Nails Hair Formula scores 75.0/100 overall while Shivay Herbals Marine Collagen scores 70.0/100. Solgar Skin Nails Hair Formula comes out ahead, scoring higher on effectiveness (76.0 vs 65.0). Solgar Skin Nails Hair Formula is best suited for Women experiencing brittle or slow-growing nails and Those with postpartum hair thinning or increased shedding. Shivay Herbals Marine Collagen is better for Budget-conscious shoppers seeking an affordable daily collagen habit and People who dislike the taste, smell, or texture of collagen powders and liquids.

Is Solgar Skin Nails Hair Formula worth the price compared to Shivay Herbals Marine Collagen? ▼

Solgar Skin Nails Hair Formula costs £12.87 while Shivay Herbals Marine Collagen is £9.99. For value, Solgar Skin Nails Hair Formula scores 70.0/100 vs Shivay Herbals Marine Collagen's 91.0/100. Shivay Herbals Marine Collagen delivers better value relative to its quality. Note that Solgar Skin Nails Hair Formula comes as tablet while Shivay Herbals Marine Collagen is ‎capsule, which may affect your preference.

Which has fewer side effects? ▼

Solgar Skin Nails Hair Formula scores 78.0/100 for side effects (higher means fewer reported issues) while Shivay Herbals Marine Collagen scores 93.0/100. Reviewers report fewer side effects with Shivay Herbals Marine Collagen. For certification and testing, Solgar Skin Nails Hair Formula scores 45.0/100 vs Shivay Herbals Marine Collagen's 38.0/100. Always consult a healthcare professional before starting any supplement.