Skip to content

Optimum Nutrition Marshmallow Crunch Bar vs PhD Smart Protein Bar, Chocolate Peanut Butter, 12 x 64g

Ad: we earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never affects our scores or rankings. How we make money

Side-by-side comparison of scores, ingredients, prices and real customer feedback for Optimum Nutrition Marshmallow Crunch Bar and PhD Smart Protein Bar, Chocolate Peanut Butter, 12 x 64g.

Last verified: 19 Oct 2026 · Based on 47 reviews

80.0
Score Summary

Optimum Nutrition Marshmallow Crunch Bar scores 80.0/100 vs PhD Smart Protein Bar, Chocolate Peanut Butter, 12 x 64g at 62.0/100. Optimum Nutrition Marshmallow Crunch Bar wins on effectiveness, ingredient quality, value for money.

How Do the Scores Compare?

Marshmallow Crunch Protein Bar 65g
PhD Smart Protein Bar, Choc...
Marshmallow Crunch Protein Bar 65g
Marshmallow Crunch Protein Bar 65g
Optimum Nutrition
PhD Smart Protein Bar, Chocolate Peanut Butter, 12 x 64g
PhD Smart Protein Bar, Choc...
PhD
Overall Score 80.0 62.0
Effectiveness 80.0/100
Best
68.0/100
Ingredient Quality 70.0/100
Best
56.0/100
Value for Money 80.0/100
Best
60.0/100
Side Effects 80.0/100
Best
72.0/100
Certifications 30.0/100
Best
25.0/100
Best Price £2.20 Amazon UK →
Out of stock
£24.99 Amazon UK →
Cheapest
Form Bar Bar
Dose N/A N/A
Third-Party Tested ✗ No ✗ No
Reviews Analysed 4 43

Marshmallow Crunch Protein Bar 65g

Pros

  • ✓Excellent taste and texture - all reviewers specifically commended flavor profile
  • ✓High protein content (20g) with no added sugar, supporting muscle support goals
  • ✓Competitively priced compared to other premium protein bar brands
  • ✓Vegetarian-friendly formula

Cons

  • ✗Contains multiple major allergens (gluten, milk, eggs, nuts, soy, peanuts) - unsuitable for those with allergies or severe intolerances
  • ✗Not third-party tested - no independent verification of nutrient claims or purity
  • ✗Not vegan - contains animal-derived ingredients, limiting accessibility
  • ✗Contains naturally occurring sugars despite 'no added sugar' marketing - total sugar content not disclosed in reviews

Best For

Gym enthusiasts and athletes seeking post-workout snacks People wanting high-protein convenience foods with good taste Those following low-added-sugar diets Vegetarians
View full review →

PhD Smart Protein Bar, Chocolate...

Pros

  • ✓Many reviewers praise the taste, with several calling it the best protein bar they've tried or better than real chocolate bars
  • ✓High protein and low sugar; one reviewer says it has a good protein-to-calorie ratio
  • ✓Filling for its size: reviewers say it keeps them going through an afternoon break or after training
  • ✓One reviewer finds the long, thin shape easier to eat than chunkier bars and says it doesn't have a powdery texture

Cons

  • ✗Many reviewers say a recipe change made it worse: firmer texture, no caramel layer and an unpleasant bitter, chemical or sickly aftertaste
  • ✗A few reviewers call it overpriced unless it's on offer
  • ✗Two reviewers got boxes with fewer than 12 bars, and one received opened packaging
  • ✗One reviewer says the bars came with a white coating and had melted once, and another felt the bars had shrunk in mass

Best For

Gym-goers and swimmers wanting a convenient protein snack after training People cutting sugar who don't mind a less sweet taste Anyone who wants a chewy, chocolate-bar-style protein snack and buys when it's discounted
View full review →

Score Breakdown: Optimum Nutrition Marshmallow Crunch Bar vs PhD Smart Protein Bar, Chocolate Peanut Butter, 12 x 64g

Optimum Nutrition Marshmallow Crunch Bar Winner 80.0/100

Optimum Nutrition's Marshmallow Crunch Protein Bar is a 20g protein bar with white chocolate and marshmallow flavour, receiving unanimous 5-star ratings from all 4 Holland & Barrett reviewers.

Effectiveness
Marshmallow Crun..
80.0/100
PhD Smart Protei..
68.0/100
Ingredient Quality
Marshmallow Crun..
70.0/100
PhD Smart Protei..
56.0/100
Value for Money
Marshmallow Crun..
80.0/100
PhD Smart Protei..
60.0/100
Side Effects
Marshmallow Crun..
80.0/100
PhD Smart Protei..
72.0/100
Certifications
Marshmallow Crun..
30.0/100
PhD Smart Protei..
25.0/100

What are the key differences?

Optimum Nutrition Marshmallow Crunch Bar is best for: Gym enthusiasts and athletes seeking post-workout snacks, People wanting high-protein convenience foods with good taste
PhD Smart Protein Bar, Chocolate Peanut Butter, 12 x 64g is best for: Gym-goers and swimmers wanting a convenient protein snack after training, People cutting sugar who don't mind a less sweet taste

Frequently Asked Questions

Which is better, Optimum Nutrition Marshmallow Crunch Bar or PhD Smart Protein Bar, Chocolate Peanut Butter, 12 x 64g? ▼
Optimum Nutrition Marshmallow Crunch Bar scores 80.0/100 overall while PhD Smart Protein Bar, Chocolate Peanut Butter, 12 x 64g scores 62.0/100. Optimum Nutrition Marshmallow Crunch Bar comes out ahead, scoring higher on effectiveness (80.0 vs 68.0). Optimum Nutrition Marshmallow Crunch Bar is best suited for Gym enthusiasts and athletes seeking post-workout snacks and People wanting high-protein convenience foods with good taste. PhD Smart Protein Bar, Chocolate Peanut Butter, 12 x 64g is better for Gym-goers and swimmers wanting a convenient protein snack after training and People cutting sugar who don't mind a less sweet taste.
Is Optimum Nutrition Marshmallow Crunch Bar worth the price compared to PhD Smart Protein Bar, Chocolate Peanut Butter, 12 x 64g? ▼
Optimum Nutrition Marshmallow Crunch Bar costs £2.20 while PhD Smart Protein Bar, Chocolate Peanut Butter, 12 x 64g is £24.99. For value, Optimum Nutrition Marshmallow Crunch Bar scores 80.0/100 vs PhD Smart Protein Bar, Chocolate Peanut Butter, 12 x 64g's 60.0/100. Optimum Nutrition Marshmallow Crunch Bar delivers better value relative to its quality.
Which has fewer side effects? ▼
Optimum Nutrition Marshmallow Crunch Bar scores 80.0/100 for side effects (higher means fewer reported issues) while PhD Smart Protein Bar, Chocolate Peanut Butter, 12 x 64g scores 72.0/100. Reviewers report fewer side effects with Optimum Nutrition Marshmallow Crunch Bar. For certification and testing, Optimum Nutrition Marshmallow Crunch Bar scores 30.0/100 vs PhD Smart Protein Bar, Chocolate Peanut Butter, 12 x 64g's 25.0/100. Always consult a healthcare professional before starting any supplement.

Related Product Comparisons

Disclaimer: AIScored provides data-driven comparisons based on publicly available reviews. This is not medical advice. Affiliate links may earn us a commission at no extra cost to you.

Feedback & Suggestions

Spotted an issue? Wrong price, incorrect data, or something else off? Let us know and we'll fix it.

Missing a product you'd like us to review? Tell us the product name and we'll consider adding it.