Skip to content

Nutravita Magnesium 5-in-1 vs Solgar Calcium Magnesium + Zinc

Ad: we earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never affects our scores or rankings. How we make money

Side-by-side comparison of scores, ingredients, prices and real customer feedback for Nutravita Magnesium 5-in-1 and Solgar Calcium Magnesium + Zinc.

Last verified: 14 Oct 2026 · Based on 59 reviews

73.0
Score Summary

Nutravita Magnesium 5-in-1 scores 73.0/100 vs Solgar Calcium Magnesium + Zinc at 67.0/100. Nutravita Magnesium 5-in-1 wins on ingredient quality, value for money, side effects.

How Do the Scores Compare?

Nutravita Magnesium Supplem...
Calcium Magnesium plus Zinc...
Nutravita Magnesium Supplements 5-in-1 Complex 1146mg - Which? Best Buy 2025-240 High Strength Capsules - 400mg Elemental Magnesium: Bisglycinate, Citrate, Malate, Oxide, Ascorbate - Muscles & Sleep
Nutravita Magnesium Supplem...
Nutravita
Calcium Magnesium plus Zinc 250 Tablets
Calcium Magnesium plus Zinc...
Solgar
Overall Score 73.0 67.0
Effectiveness 72.0/100
Best
72.0/100
Best
Ingredient Quality 64.0/100
Best
58.0/100
Value for Money 82.0/100
Best
76.0/100
Side Effects 85.0/100
Best
82.0/100
Certifications 68.0/100
Best
30.0/100
Best Price
£19.99
£15.19 Amazon UK →
-24% deal
£18.75
£14.72 Amazon UK →
-21% deal
Price per Serving £0.13 120 servings £0.06 250 servings
Best value
Form Capsule tablet
Dose N/A N/A
Third-Party Tested ✗ No ✗ No
Reviews Analysed 10 49

Nutravita Magnesium Supplements ...

Pros

  • ✓Multiple reviewers report genuine improvements in night-time muscle cramps and sleep depth
  • ✓400mg elemental magnesium is a full therapeutic dose — not token amounts
  • ✓Includes bisglycinate and citrate, two of the best-absorbed forms available
  • ✓Which? Best Buy 2025 rating and UK GMP/BRC manufacturing standards

Cons

  • ✗Magnesium oxide is the lowest-bioavailability form (~4%) and pads the blend without proportional benefit
  • ✗Per-form ratios are not disclosed — you cannot tell how much bisglycinate versus oxide you're actually getting
  • ✗Not independently third-party tested; GMP/BRC covers manufacturing process, not label accuracy
  • ✗One reviewer explicitly notes this is a suboptimal choice if sleep is the primary goal — glycinate or L-threonate alone may work better

Best For

People wanting broad daily magnesium cover — muscles, nerve function, energy — rather than a targeted single-form protocol Those experiencing muscle cramps or night-time leg restlessness, where the citrate and bisglycinate fractions should help Budget-conscious buyers who want multiple premium forms without buying four separate products
View full review →

Calcium Magnesium plus Zinc 250 Tablets

Pros

  • ✓Several reviewers report fewer leg cramps, night cramps and muscle spasms, some within about 10 days to a couple of weeks
  • ✓Multiple users say they sleep more deeply when they take it in the evening or before bed
  • ✓Calcium, magnesium and zinc in one tablet, at 1000mg, 400mg and 15mg per serving, so you don't need to buy three separate products
  • ✓Suitable for vegans. Most reviewers find the tablets tasteless, though a couple describe the taste as sweet or pleasant, and many praise the glass jar

Cons

  • ✗Tablets are large. Many reviewers mention this, even those who still find them easy to swallow with enough water
  • ✗Magnesium oxide and calcium carbonate are cheaper forms and are absorbed less well than the citrate and gluconate also in the blend
  • ✗The full serving is a heavy mineral load. One reviewer would rather take smaller portions, and another takes two tablets instead of three
  • ✗Not third-party tested, and there are no certifications in the specs

Best For

People with frequent leg cramps or night-time muscle spasms Vegans and vegetarians who want calcium, magnesium and zinc in a single product Older adults wanting extra bone support, including reviewers aged 40+ and 65 Anyone who takes minerals in the evening as part of a bedtime routine
View full review →

Score Breakdown: Nutravita Magnesium 5-in-1 vs Solgar Calcium Magnesium + Zinc

Nutravita Magnesium 5-in-1 Winner 73.0/100

Four hundred milligrams of elemental magnesium per two-capsule serving sounds generous, but the blend quality is uneven: bisglycinate and citrate are genuinely good forms, malate earns its place for energy metabolism, yet oxide — with roughly 4% bioavailability — is bulk filler that inflates the headline number.

Effectiveness
Nutravita Magnes..
72.0/100
Calcium Magnesiu..
72.0/100
Ingredient Quality
Nutravita Magnes..
64.0/100
Calcium Magnesiu..
58.0/100
Value for Money
Nutravita Magnes..
82.0/100
Calcium Magnesiu..
76.0/100
Side Effects
Nutravita Magnes..
85.0/100
Calcium Magnesiu..
82.0/100
Certifications
Nutravita Magnes..
68.0/100
Calcium Magnesiu..
30.0/100

What are the key differences?

Nutravita Magnesium 5-in-1 is best for: People wanting broad daily magnesium cover — muscles, nerve function, energy — rather than a targeted single-form protocol, Those experiencing muscle cramps or night-time leg restlessness, where the citrate and bisglycinate fractions should help
Solgar Calcium Magnesium + Zinc is best for: People with frequent leg cramps or night-time muscle spasms, Vegans and vegetarians who want calcium, magnesium and zinc in a single product

Frequently Asked Questions

Which is better, Nutravita Magnesium 5-in-1 or Solgar Calcium Magnesium + Zinc? ▼
Nutravita Magnesium 5-in-1 scores 73.0/100 overall while Solgar Calcium Magnesium + Zinc scores 67.0/100. Nutravita Magnesium 5-in-1 comes out ahead, scoring higher on effectiveness (72.0 vs 72.0). Nutravita Magnesium 5-in-1 is best suited for People wanting broad daily magnesium cover — muscles, nerve function, energy — rather than a targeted single-form protocol and Those experiencing muscle cramps or night-time leg restlessness, where the citrate and bisglycinate fractions should help. Solgar Calcium Magnesium + Zinc is better for People with frequent leg cramps or night-time muscle spasms and Vegans and vegetarians who want calcium, magnesium and zinc in a single product.
Is Nutravita Magnesium 5-in-1 worth the price compared to Solgar Calcium Magnesium + Zinc? ▼
Nutravita Magnesium 5-in-1 costs £15.19 while Solgar Calcium Magnesium + Zinc is £14.72. For value, Nutravita Magnesium 5-in-1 scores 82.0/100 vs Solgar Calcium Magnesium + Zinc's 76.0/100. Nutravita Magnesium 5-in-1 delivers better value relative to its quality. Note that Nutravita Magnesium 5-in-1 comes as capsule while Solgar Calcium Magnesium + Zinc is tablet, which may affect your preference.
Which has fewer side effects? ▼
Nutravita Magnesium 5-in-1 scores 85.0/100 for side effects (higher means fewer reported issues) while Solgar Calcium Magnesium + Zinc scores 82.0/100. Reviewers report fewer side effects with Nutravita Magnesium 5-in-1. For certification and testing, Nutravita Magnesium 5-in-1 scores 68.0/100 vs Solgar Calcium Magnesium + Zinc's 30.0/100. Always consult a healthcare professional before starting any supplement.

Related Product Comparisons

VS

Nutravita Magnesium Supplements 5-in-1 Complex 1146mg - Which? Best Buy 2025-240 High Strength Capsules - 400mg Elemental Magnesium: Bisglycinate, Citrate, Malate, Oxide, Ascorbate - Muscles & Sleep

vs Doctor's Best High Absorption Magnesium 100mg

VS

Nutravita Magnesium Supplements 5-in-1 Complex 1146mg - Which? Best Buy 2025-240 High Strength Capsules - 400mg Elemental Magnesium: Bisglycinate, Citrate, Malate, Oxide, Ascorbate - Muscles & Sleep

vs Life Extension Neuro-Mag Magnesium L-Threonate

VS

Nutravita Magnesium Supplements 5-in-1 Complex 1146mg - Which? Best Buy 2025-240 High Strength Capsules - 400mg Elemental Magnesium: Bisglycinate, Citrate, Malate, Oxide, Ascorbate - Muscles & Sleep

vs High Potency Magnesium 300mg 120 Capsules

VS

Nutravita Magnesium Supplements 5-in-1 Complex 1146mg - Which? Best Buy 2025-240 High Strength Capsules - 400mg Elemental Magnesium: Bisglycinate, Citrate, Malate, Oxide, Ascorbate - Muscles & Sleep

vs Magnesium Citrate 700mg - 180 Vegan Tablets - 6 Month Supply - Providing 200mg of Elemental Magnesium per Tablet - Made in the UK - Nu U Nutrition

VS

Nutravita Magnesium Supplements 5-in-1 Complex 1146mg - Which? Best Buy 2025-240 High Strength Capsules - 400mg Elemental Magnesium: Bisglycinate, Citrate, Malate, Oxide, Ascorbate - Muscles & Sleep

vs Magnesium Glycinate 3-in-1 Complex - 1800mg Supplements as Bisglycinate, Citrate & Malate 90 Vegan Capsules, Triple High Absorption 384mg Elemental, UK Made

VS

Nutravita Magnesium Supplements 5-in-1 Complex 1146mg - Which? Best Buy 2025-240 High Strength Capsules - 400mg Elemental Magnesium: Bisglycinate, Citrate, Malate, Oxide, Ascorbate - Muscles & Sleep

vs BetterYou Magnesium Body Spray

What the Data Says

Why is magnesium oxide less effective than glycinate?

Oxide scores 21 points lower than glycinate in our testing — and it's not close on ingredient quality either. Across 17 magnesium products in our database, glycinate averages 74.3/100 overall. Oxide sits at 53/100. That's a gap you can feel.

The ingredient quality difference is even starker: 83.3 for glycinate vs 37.0 for oxide. A 46.3-point gap. The best glycinate in our database, Solgar Magnesium Glycinate 400mg, scores 80/100 overall with 88/100 on ingredient quality. The oxide product (Nature Made) manages just 52 on effectiveness and 37 on ingredient quality.

The reason is bioavailability. Magnesium oxide has roughly 4% absorption — most of it passes straight through your gut unused. Glycinate is chelated (bound to the amino acid glycine), which your intestines absorb much more efficiently. You also get fewer digestive side effects, since unabsorbed magnesium in the gut is what causes the laxative effect oxide is known for.

Oxide is cheap, which is why it's still everywhere. But cheap per pill means nothing if your body can't use it. Glycinate or citrate (avg 74.5/100) are both better choices.

Which form of magnesium is best for sleep, anxiety, or muscle cramps?

Glycinate for sleep and anxiety. Citrate for cramps. L-threonate for brain function. Each form has a different strength, and our scores back this up.

Sleep and anxiety → Glycinate. Averaging 74.3/100 across our database, with the best (Solgar Glycinate 400mg) hitting 80/100. Glycine, the amino acid it's bound to, acts as an inhibitory neurotransmitter — it calms your nervous system on its own. That's a two-for-one benefit you don't get from other forms. Thorne Bisglycinate (74/100) is another solid option at a lower dose.

Muscle cramps → Citrate. Averaging 74.5/100 overall with 85.0 on ingredient quality. Citrate absorbs well and is gentler on your wallet than glycinate. Solgar Citrate leads the pack at 77/100. If cramps are your main issue, this is the practical choice.

Brain function → L-Threonate. Life Extension Neuro-Mag scores 73/100. This is the only form shown to meaningfully raise magnesium levels in the brain by crossing the blood-brain barrier. It's pricier, but nothing else does what it does.

All-round absorption → Doctor's Best High Absorption tops our entire magnesium database at 82/100 overall (83 effectiveness, 88 ingredient quality) using chelated magnesium.

The one form to skip? Oxide at 53/100. Its 4% absorption rate makes it a poor choice no matter what you're taking it for.

Disclaimer: AIScored provides data-driven comparisons based on publicly available reviews. This is not medical advice. Affiliate links may earn us a commission at no extra cost to you.

Feedback & Suggestions

Spotted an issue? Wrong price, incorrect data, or something else off? Let us know and we'll fix it.

Missing a product you'd like us to review? Tell us the product name and we'll consider adding it.