Pooch & Mutt Health & Digestion Salmon vs Lily's Kitchen Classic & Grain-Free
Ad: we earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never affects our scores or rankings. How we make money
Side-by-side comparison of scores, ingredients, prices and real customer feedback for Pooch & Mutt Health & Digestion Salmon and Lily's Kitchen Classic & Grain-Free.
Last verified: 19 Oct 2026 · Based on 20 reviews
Pooch & Mutt Health & Digestion Salmon scores 81.0/100 vs Lily's Kitchen Classic & Grain-Free at 77.0/100. Pooch & Mutt Health & Digestion Salmon wins on ingredient quality, nutritional value, transparency. Lily's Kitchen Classic & Grain-Free is stronger on value for money.
How Do the Scores Compare?
Pooch & Mutt - Health & Dig...
Pooch & Mutt
|
Lily's Kitchen Natural Adul...
Lily's Kitchen
|
|
|---|---|---|
| Overall Score | 81.0 | 77.0 |
| Ingredient Quality |
84.0/100
Best
|
82.0/100 |
| Nutritional Value |
78.0/100
Best
|
72.0/100 |
| Value for Money | 66.0/100 |
70.0/100
Best
|
| Transparency |
89.0/100
Best
|
68.0/100 |
| Palatability |
90.0/100
Best
|
86.0/100 |
| Best Price |
£15.99
£12.00
Amazon UK →
-25% deal
|
£34.19
£34.00
Amazon UK →
-1% deal
|
| Form | N/A | N/A |
| Dose | N/A | N/A |
| Third-Party Tested | ✗ No | ✗ No |
| Reviews Analysed | 13 | 7 |
Pooch & Mutt - Health & Digestio...
Pros
- ✓45% named salmon as single protein source — high digestibility, rich in omega-3s, ideal for elimination diets
- ✓Prebiotics included to actively support gut flora balance, not just passive fibre
- ✓Exceptionally high palatability — accepted by picky and fussy dogs across multiple breeds
- ✓Completely free from grains, gluten, by-products, meat meal, and artificial additives — strong ingredient transparency
Cons
- ✗Premium price point — above average cost per kg compared to mainstream grain-free options
- ✗Occasional reports of skin itching, consistent with individual salmon protein sensitivity
- ✗Grain-free formulas remain under ongoing veterinary and FDA scrutiny for potential links to dilated cardiomyopathy (DCM) in some breeds
- ✗2kg pack size offers relatively poor value per kg for medium-to-large breeds with higher daily feeding volumes
Best For
Lily's Kitchen Natural Adult Wet...
Pros
- ✓Named fresh meat is the first ingredient in every listed recipe, at 45-60% of the tin, with no by-products or meat meal
- ✓Every review is five stars, and two reviewers say a fussy eater takes to it
- ✓One reviewer says the varied tins have a pleasant aroma that quickly draws their dog in
- ✓Two reviewers say it is cheaper than buying it in supermarkets
Cons
- ✗Not fully grain-free: the Classic Dinners Chicken & Turkey Casserole contains pearl barley and brown rice, which matters if you bought it to avoid grains
- ✗Ingredient lists for the three grain-free tins (Sunday Lunch, Fishy Fish Pie, Wild Campfire Stew) aren't given here, so half the bundle can't be checked
- ✗No analytical constituents (protein, fat, fibre, moisture) are listed, so the nutrition claims can't be verified
- ✗The herb blend lists 12 botanicals with no amounts, so they are probably there for label appeal more than any proven effect
Best For
Score Breakdown: Pooch & Mutt Health & Digestion Salmon vs Lily's Kitchen Classic & Grain-Free
Pooch & Mutt Health & Digestion is a premium grain-free kibble built around 45% salmon as a single, named protein source, paired with sweet potato as the primary carbohydrate — an ingredient profile that avoids common allergens while delivering high levels of omega-3 fatty acids (EPA/DHA) beneficial to coat, skin, and joint health.
What are the key differences?
Frequently Asked Questions
Which is better, Pooch & Mutt Health & Digestion Salmon or Lily's Kitchen Classic & Grain-Free? ▼
Is Pooch & Mutt Health & Digestion Salmon worth the price compared to Lily's Kitchen Classic & Grain-Free? ▼
Which has fewer side effects? ▼
Related Product Comparisons
Complete Natural Adult Dog Food Wet (10 x 150g Trays)
vs Pooch & Mutt - Health & Digestion, Complete Dry Dog Food (Grain Free), Salmon and Sweet Potato, 2kg
Complete Natural Adult Dog Food Wet (10 x 150g Trays)
vs Lily's Kitchen Natural Adult Wet Dog Food Tins Classic Dinners Variety Pack 6 x 400g & Natural Adult Wet Dog Food Tins Grain-Free Recipe Variety Pack 6 x 400g
Lily's Kitchen Made with Natural Ingredients Adult Small Breed Dry Dog Food Chicken & Duck Grain-Free Recipe 2.5kg
vs Pooch & Mutt - Health & Digestion, Complete Dry Dog Food (Grain Free), Salmon and Sweet Potato, 2kg
Lily's Kitchen Made with Natural Ingredients Adult Small Breed Dry Dog Food Chicken & Duck Grain-Free Recipe 2.5kg
vs Lily's Kitchen Natural Adult Wet Dog Food Tins Classic Dinners Variety Pack 6 x 400g & Natural Adult Wet Dog Food Tins Grain-Free Recipe Variety Pack 6 x 400g
Lily's Kitchen Natural Adult Wet Dog Food Tray Cottage Pie Grain-Free Recipe 10 x 150g
vs Pooch & Mutt - Health & Digestion, Complete Dry Dog Food (Grain Free), Salmon and Sweet Potato, 2kg
Lily's Kitchen Natural Adult Wet Dog Food Tray Cottage Pie Grain-Free Recipe 10 x 150g
vs Lily's Kitchen Natural Adult Wet Dog Food Tins Classic Dinners Variety Pack 6 x 400g & Natural Adult Wet Dog Food Tins Grain-Free Recipe Variety Pack 6 x 400g
What the Data Says
Is grain-free dog food actually better? What the data shows.
Grain-free leads on every metric, but the gap is smaller than marketing suggests. We scored 27 grain-free and 73 standard dry dog foods across the same criteria.
The numbers: grain-free averages 75.1/100 overall versus 71.5 for standard — a 3.6-point lead. Break it down by category and the picture gets more interesting.
Ingredient quality is where grain-free pulls ahead most: 77.8 versus 71.2, a 6.6-point gap. Grain-free brands tend to use higher meat content and fewer cheap bulking agents. Transparency is the second-largest gap: 74.9 versus 69.8 (5.1 points) — grain-free brands are generally more upfront about sourcing and ingredient percentages.
But nutritional value tells a different story: 72.1 versus 70.0, just 2.1 points apart. That's the smallest gap of any metric. Removing grains doesn't automatically make a food more nutritious.
Bottom line: if your dog has a diagnosed grain intolerance, grain-free is the right call. If not, a high-scoring standard food delivers nearly identical nutrition at a lower price point.
Do grain-free dog foods hide carbohydrate fillers?
Grain-free scores better on transparency (74.9 vs 69.8), but grain-free does not mean low-carb. That 5.1-point transparency gap across 27 grain-free and 73 standard products means grain-free brands are more likely to disclose ingredient percentages and sourcing details.
The catch: most grain-free formulas replace rice, wheat, or corn with peas, lentils, chickpeas, or sweet potato. These are still carbohydrate sources. Some grain-free products list two or three legume variants in the first five ingredients, pushing total carbohydrate content to 40-50% of the formula.
Here's how to check: read the analytical constituents on the back of the bag. If protein is 25% and fat is 15%, the remaining 60% is mostly carbohydrates, moisture, and fibre. That's true whether the carbs come from brown rice or sweet potato.
The grain-free label tells you what's absent, not what replaced it. Higher transparency scores mean these brands make it easier for you to verify the substitution yourself — but you still need to look.
Disclaimer: AIScored provides data-driven comparisons based on publicly available reviews. This is not medical advice. Affiliate links may earn us a commission at no extra cost to you.
Feedback & Suggestions
Spotted an issue? Wrong price, incorrect data, or something else off? Let us know and we'll fix it.
Missing a product you'd like us to review? Tell us the product name and we'll consider adding it.