Edgard & Cooper Puppy Duck & Chicken vs Dr John Puppy Chicken
Side-by-side comparison of scores, ingredients, prices and real customer feedback for Edgard & Cooper Puppy Duck & Chicken and Dr John Puppy Chicken.
Last verified: 01 Mar 2026 · Based on 26 reviews
Our Verdict: Edgard & Cooper Puppy Duck & Chicken or Dr John Puppy Chicken?
Edgard Cooper edges ahead with higher ingredient quality (82 vs 73) and effectiveness scores, making it the better pick for puppies with grain sensitivities or fussy appetites. Dr John is the wiser choice for active or sporting breed owners on a budget — at £19.27 for 10kg, it delivers exceptional value with consistent palatability.
— AIScored Editorial Team
Edgard & Cooper Puppy Duck & Chicken scores 77.0/100 vs Dr John Puppy Chicken at 76.0/100. Edgard & Cooper Puppy Duck & Chicken wins on ingredient quality, transparency. Dr John Puppy Chicken is stronger on value for money and palatability.
Edgard & Cooper Puppy Duck & Chicken vs Dr John Puppy Chicken: What Does the Data Say?
Edgard & Cooper's wet food and Dr John's dry kibble serve quite different purposes, and that difference in format shapes almost everything else. Edgard & Cooper comes in 150g cups of wet food made with named duck and chicken — real, fresh meat rather than dried or rendered derivatives — and includes prebiotics to support a puppy's developing gut. At £15.25 for 11 cups, you're paying for a natural, minimally processed recipe. Dr John, by contrast, is a 10kg bag of dry kibble built around chicken and salmon, with salmon oil added to deliver DHA and EPA omega-3s. That omega-3 provision is genuinely useful for brain and eye development, and the named ingredients are reassuring for the price — just £19.27 for a bag that'll last considerably longer than 11 wet cups.
The scores reflect the trade-offs clearly. Edgard & Cooper scores 77/100, with ingredient quality and effectiveness both at 82, but value trails at 76 — wet food is inherently more expensive per calorie. Dr John scores 76/100 overall, but its value score of 81 is the clear highlight; effectiveness and ingredient quality sit at 73, partly because the carbohydrate base is relatively heavy and the formula is tuned for sporting and working breeds rather than all puppy types.
If you have a fussy or grain-sensitive puppy, or a small-to-medium breed that needs high moisture intake, Edgard & Cooper is the more considered option — though be aware the 150g cups won't stretch to large-breed portions without cost mounting quickly. Dr John makes more sense for owners of active or working-breed puppies on a tighter budget who want a palatable, named-meat dry food that'll last.
How Do the Scores Compare?
Edgard Cooper Puppy Grain-F...
Edgard Coop
|
Dr John Dry Puppy Food 10kg...
Gilbertson & Pag
|
|
|---|---|---|
| Overall Score | 77.0 | 76.0 |
| Ingredient Quality |
82.0/100
Best
|
73.0/100 |
| Nutritional Value |
74.0/100
Best
|
74.0/100
Best
|
| Value for Money | 76.0/100 |
81.0/100
Best
|
| Transparency |
83.0/100
Best
|
69.0/100 |
| Palatability | 71.0/100 |
85.0/100
Best
|
| Best Price |
£16.39
Amazon UK →
Cheapest
|
£25.49
£19.29
Amazon UK →
-24% deal
|
| Form | ||
| Dose | ||
| Third-Party Tested | ✗ No | ✗ No |
| Reviews Analysed | 14 | 12 |
Edgard Cooper Puppy Grain-Free W...
Pros
- ✓Named meat sources (duck and chicken) — no generic by-products or meat meal
- ✓Grain-free and natural formula with no over-processed or dried meat
- ✓Prebiotics included to support healthy gut development in puppies
- ✓Strong palatability reported by fussy-dog owners switching from other premium brands
Cons
- ✗Palatability is inconsistent — a minority of dogs flatly refuse it with no clear pattern
- ✗150g portion sizes are small for large-breed puppies (25–45 kg), requiring multiple cups per meal
- ✗Grain-free formulas for large-breed puppies require careful calcium/phosphorus balancing — not always verifiable from marketing copy alone
- ✗Some non-English reviews suggest this product is widely distributed internationally but reviewed outside UK context, diluting UK-specific palatability signal
Best For
Dr John Dry Puppy Food 10kg with...
Pros
- ✓Named chicken and salmon — no vague meat derivatives or by-products
- ✓Salmon oil provides DHA/EPA Omega-3s, supporting puppy brain and visual development
- ✓Dogs consistently reported to enjoy the taste and smell across multiple reviews
- ✓Prebiotics and dietary fibre for healthy digestion; owners report firm, consistent stools
Cons
- ✗Formulated primarily for sporting and working breed puppies — not optimised for large/giant breed puppies who need controlled calcium and phosphorus levels
- ✗Carbohydrate base is likely rice/grain-heavy (noted by reviewers), which, while digestible, dilutes overall meat content
- ✗Exact named-meat inclusion percentage not published, limiting full ingredient quality assessment
- ✗Yucca extract provides mild joint support but at typical inclusion rates the benefit is marginal
Best For
Score Breakdown: Edgard & Cooper Puppy Duck & Chicken vs Dr John Puppy Chicken
Edgard & Cooper's grain-free puppy wet food uses named duck and chicken as primary protein sources — a strong transparency marker and a step above vague 'meat derivatives' common in lower-tier brands.
What are the key differences?
Frequently Asked Questions
Which is better, Edgard & Cooper Puppy Duck & Chicken or Dr John Puppy Chicken? ▼
Is Edgard & Cooper Puppy Duck & Chicken worth the price compared to Dr John Puppy Chicken? ▼
Which has fewer side effects? ▼
Related Product Comparisons
Alpha Sporting Puppy Dry Dog Food
vs Edgard Cooper Puppy Grain-Free Wet Dog Food, Duck Chicken 11 x 150g, Natural Dogs Food in Cup with Fresh Meat Amino Acids, Gluten-Free, High Protein
Alpha Sporting Puppy Dry Dog Food
vs Dr John Dry Puppy Food 10kg with Omega-3s - Chicken Recipe - Complete Nutrition for Puppies of Sporting Active Breeds - Junior High Protein Dry Dog Food.
Kibble + Raw Puppy Food - Free Run Turkey (5 x 1.5kg) ❘ Nutritious High Protein Kibble Combined with Freeze-Dried Raw Meat Nuggets, Contains Essential Oils & Minerals, Grain & Gluten Free
vs Edgard Cooper Puppy Grain-Free Wet Dog Food, Duck Chicken 11 x 150g, Natural Dogs Food in Cup with Fresh Meat Amino Acids, Gluten-Free, High Protein
Kibble + Raw Puppy Food - Free Run Turkey (5 x 1.5kg) ❘ Nutritious High Protein Kibble Combined with Freeze-Dried Raw Meat Nuggets, Contains Essential Oils & Minerals, Grain & Gluten Free
vs Dr John Dry Puppy Food 10kg with Omega-3s - Chicken Recipe - Complete Nutrition for Puppies of Sporting Active Breeds - Junior High Protein Dry Dog Food.
PRO PLAN Medium Puppy Healthy Start up to 12-15 Months Dry Dog Food Chicken 3kg Pack
vs Edgard Cooper Puppy Grain-Free Wet Dog Food, Duck Chicken 11 x 150g, Natural Dogs Food in Cup with Fresh Meat Amino Acids, Gluten-Free, High Protein
PRO PLAN Medium Puppy Healthy Start up to 12-15 Months Dry Dog Food Chicken 3kg Pack
vs Dr John Dry Puppy Food 10kg with Omega-3s - Chicken Recipe - Complete Nutrition for Puppies of Sporting Active Breeds - Junior High Protein Dry Dog Food.
Disclaimer: AIScored provides data-driven comparisons based on publicly available reviews. This is not medical advice. Affiliate links may earn us a commission at no extra cost to you.
Feedback & Suggestions
Spotted an issue? Wrong price, incorrect data, or something else off? Let us know and we'll fix it.
Missing a product you'd like us to review? Tell us the product name and we'll consider adding it.