Skip to content

Natures Menu Freeze Dried Beef vs COYA Freeze-Dried Fish

Ad: we earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never affects our scores or rankings. How we make money

Side-by-side comparison of scores, ingredients, prices and real customer feedback for Natures Menu Freeze Dried Beef and COYA Freeze-Dried Fish.

Last verified: 01 Mar 2026 · Based on 25 reviews

80.0
Score Summary

Natures Menu Freeze Dried Beef scores 80.0/100 vs COYA Freeze-Dried Fish at 72.0/100. Natures Menu Freeze Dried Beef wins on ingredient quality, nutritional value, value for money.

How Do the Scores Compare?

Natures Menu Freeze Dried C...
Freeze-Dried Dog Food, Fish...
Natures Menu Freeze Dried Complete & Balanced Dog Food Nuggets - Beef - 250g
Natures Menu Freeze Dried C...
Natures Menu
Freeze-Dried Dog Food, Fish (150g) Hypoallergenic & Grain Free, Made With 80% Fish & 20% Fruits & Veggies
Freeze-Dried Dog Food, Fish...
COYA
Overall Score 80.0 72.0
Ingredient Quality 91.0/100
Best
83.0/100
Nutritional Value 84.0/100
Best
79.0/100
Value for Money 48.0/100
Best
42.0/100
Transparency 88.0/100
Best
74.0/100
Palatability 93.0/100
Best
71.0/100
Best Price
£10.99
£8.83 Amazon UK →
-20% deal
£8.99 Amazon UK →
Form N/A N/A
Dose N/A N/A
Third-Party Tested ✗ No ✗ No
Reviews Analysed 12 13

Natures Menu Freeze Dried Comple...

Pros

  • ✓80% named beef with no by-products or meat meal — transparent, premium protein sourcing
  • ✓Freeze-drying preserves nutrients, enzymes, and bioavailability better than cooked or extruded formats
  • ✓Highly palatable — accepted by fussy eaters, grieving dogs, and allergy-sensitive dogs in reviews
  • ✓Multiple owners report improvements in digestion, skin, coat quality, and reduced allergies

Cons

  • ✗Very high cost per kg — financially impractical as a sole diet for dogs over ~10kg
  • ✗Small 250g pack size limits cost efficiency for multi-dog or larger-breed households
  • ✗Contains coconut oil (reported by one reviewer) — may be unsuitable for pancreatitis-prone dogs
  • ✗Packaging damage reported on multiple deliveries with no returns policy applied

Best For

Dogs with food sensitivities, allergies, or chronic digestive issues Fussy or appetite-reluctant eaters Raw-fed dogs needing a convenient travel or topper option Small breed adult dogs where pack size is economical Dogs recovering from illness or dental procedures (soft, crumbleable texture)
View full review →

Freeze-Dried Dog Food, Fish (150...

Pros

  • ✓Single named protein source (fish) — ideal for elimination diets and allergy management
  • ✓No by-products, no meat meal, human-grade ingredients with clear labelling
  • ✓Freeze-dried raw retains enzymes and heat-sensitive nutrients lost in cooking
  • ✓Multiple owners report improved coat condition and firmer, smaller stools

Cons

  • ✗Fish species not specified (e.g. salmon, cod, herring) — limits traceability for dogs with species-specific allergies
  • ✗Very small 150g package makes cost-per-kg extremely high; impractical as sole diet for medium-large breeds
  • ✗High fat content (32% DM) unsuitable for overweight, sedentary, or pancreatitis-prone dogs
  • ✗Palatability not universal — roughly 25% of reviewers report outright refusal despite strong smell

Best For

Dogs with food allergies or suspected protein intolerances Fussy eaters attracted by strong aroma Small breed adult dogs Active adult dogs with higher energy requirements Owners seeking raw-feeding nutrition without frozen preparation or mess
View full review →

Score Breakdown: Natures Menu Freeze Dried Beef vs COYA Freeze-Dried Fish

Natures Menu Freeze Dried Beef Winner 80.0/100

Natures Menu Freeze Dried Beef Nuggets is a high-quality, minimally processed raw dog food featuring 80% named beef with no by-products or meat meal — a composition far exceeding typical commercial dog foods.

Ingredient Quality
Natures Menu Fre..
91.0/100
Freeze-Dried Dog..
83.0/100
Nutritional Value
Natures Menu Fre..
84.0/100
Freeze-Dried Dog..
79.0/100
Value for Money
Natures Menu Fre..
48.0/100
Freeze-Dried Dog..
42.0/100
Transparency
Natures Menu Fre..
88.0/100
Freeze-Dried Dog..
74.0/100
Palatability
Natures Menu Fre..
93.0/100
Freeze-Dried Dog..
71.0/100

What are the key differences?

Natures Menu Freeze Dried Beef is best for: Dogs with food sensitivities, allergies, or chronic digestive issues, Fussy or appetite-reluctant eaters
COYA Freeze-Dried Fish is best for: Dogs with food allergies or suspected protein intolerances, Fussy eaters attracted by strong aroma

Frequently Asked Questions

Which is better, Natures Menu Freeze Dried Beef or COYA Freeze-Dried Fish? ▼
Natures Menu Freeze Dried Beef scores 80.0/100 overall while COYA Freeze-Dried Fish scores 72.0/100. Natures Menu Freeze Dried Beef comes out ahead, scoring higher on effectiveness (0 vs 0). Natures Menu Freeze Dried Beef is best suited for Dogs with food sensitivities, allergies, or chronic digestive issues and Fussy or appetite-reluctant eaters. COYA Freeze-Dried Fish is better for Dogs with food allergies or suspected protein intolerances and Fussy eaters attracted by strong aroma.
Is Natures Menu Freeze Dried Beef worth the price compared to COYA Freeze-Dried Fish? ▼
Natures Menu Freeze Dried Beef costs £8.83 while COYA Freeze-Dried Fish is £8.99. For value, Natures Menu Freeze Dried Beef scores 48.0/100 vs COYA Freeze-Dried Fish's 42.0/100. Natures Menu Freeze Dried Beef delivers better value relative to its quality.
Which has fewer side effects? ▼
Natures Menu Freeze Dried Beef scores 0/100 for side effects (higher means fewer reported issues) while COYA Freeze-Dried Fish scores 0/100. Both have similar side effect profiles based on user reviews. Always consult a healthcare professional before starting any supplement.

Related Product Comparisons

Disclaimer: AIScored provides data-driven comparisons based on publicly available reviews. This is not medical advice. Affiliate links may earn us a commission at no extra cost to you.

Feedback & Suggestions

Spotted an issue? Wrong price, incorrect data, or something else off? Let us know and we'll fix it.

Missing a product you'd like us to review? Tell us the product name and we'll consider adding it.