The Protein Works Wondershake vs Applied Critical Plant Protein

Pros

• ✓Taste consistently rated among the best in class for vegan proteins — smooth, flavourful, not artificial
• ✓Multi-source protein blend (pea + faba bean + pumpkin seed) improves amino acid completeness vs single-source
• ✓Added vegan-critical nutrients (B12, D3, iron, zinc) address common dietary gaps
• ✓Informed Sport certified — suitable for tested athletes

Cons

• ✗Contains sucralose (artificial sweetener) and xanthan gum — not a clean-label formula
• ✗Can leave undissolved residue when mixed with water or plant milk
• ✗No independent third-party testing for heavy metals or contamination beyond Informed Sport batch testing
• ✗May contain gluten and nuts due to shared facility — unsuitable for those with severe allergies

Best For

Pros

• ✓High protein yield (~24g per 30g serving) with a complete amino acid profile from the pea/soya/rice blend
• ✓Most reviewers report good mixability and a palatable taste, especially chocolate and strawberry flavours
• ✓Well-tolerated digestively by the majority—notably low bloating and gas compared to whey
• ✓Excellent value for money at the 1.8kg size (~60 servings)

Cons

• ✗Flavour divides opinion—some detect an earthy, raw-grain or 'raw potato' taste, especially vanilla
• ✗One user reported excessive foaming and found the taste unacceptable
• ✗Digestive adjustment can be significant for some users; one reviewer noted pronounced GI disruption in the first days
• ✗No third-party testing (e.g. Informed Sport) — notable absence given the soya allergen content and gym market

Best For